Below is an archived edition of Ctrl Alt Right Delete, a weekly email newsletter. This edition was published on 06/04/2017. Members of Factual Democracy Project have access to past editions. Subscribe to Ctrl Alt Right Delete.
What About Bots?
Bots have always been part of alt-right/fake news conversations but this week, they went mainstream. Hillary Clinton talked about bots extensively during her Code 2017 keynote. Meanwhile, a news story claiming the Trump had gained nearly 5 million bot twitter followers seemingly overnight was reported and quickly debunked.
Trump and other celebrities have a heavy amount of Twitter users that are in fact bots, not real people. If you’re on Twitter, you probably have bots following you as well, though likely not in as high a number or percentage as President Trump or a celebrity like Britney Spears.
Bots play a crucial role in the weaponization of fake news and propaganda. We know that the Russians have been deploying them in America since 2014 and that they’ve been deployed in Europe as well, most famously during this year’s French election. The best description of where bots fit into the frog squad’s activities that I’ve seen is Andrew Weisburd, Clint Watts, and JM Berger’s article on Russia’s strategy to influence the American Election and ultimately destroy our democracy, published just two days before the U.S. election:
A small army of social media operatives — a mix of Russian-controlled accounts, useful idiots, and innocent bystanders — are deployed to promote all of this material to unknowing audiences. Some of these are real people, others are bots, and some present themselves as innocent news aggregators, providing “breaking news alerts” to happenings worldwide or in specific cities. The latter group is a key tool for moving misinformation and disinformation from primarily Russian-influenced circles into the general social media population. We saw this phenomenon at play in recent reports of a second military coup in Turkey and unsubstantiated reports of an active shooter that led to the shutdown of JFK Airport. Some news aggregators may be directly controlled by Russia, while other aggregators that use algorithmic collection may be the victims of manipulation.
Reading this article really helped me understand what I’d observed online in 2016. The Clinton campaign was unable to break through on social media using the tactics we’d employed on the Obama reelect during debates, speeches, and other key moments. Additionally, the abuse I and others were subjected to online was so much more intense than anything I’d ever experienced. Democrats were drowned out on social media, and the press — who obsessively cover what people are saying on social media now — bore witness to what they largely assumed was happening organically online.
Clint Watts also testified before the Senate Intelligence Committee and made that point that President Trump has both benefitted from bots, and is a frequent target of bot campaigns. Watts testified that “gray outlets” tweet propaganda and disinformation at Trump with high volume at times when he’s known to be online. I assume that bots target other U.S. elected officials and world leaders in the same way, though I would also assume that none spend as much time on Twitter or are as susceptible to these tactics as Donald Trump.
The political operative in me can’t help but be impressed by this weaponization. So much of my work on campaigns involved building online communities and deploying them in large numbers at key moments. But you can’t control 100,000 human supporters on Twitter or keep them 100% on message. You can however do that with bots, and if the bot accounts seem realistic enough to pass as people, you can also create false enthusiasm and support for reporters and pundits.
Further Reading: If you want to better understand the mechanics of a botnet, Ben Nimmo’s piece for DFRLab is a good place to start. Renee DiResta’s article at ribbonfarm is also helpful for understanding how the presence of bots affects the marketplace of ideas. Slate covers where tech companies are failing on transparency about bots to the public. Farhad Manjoo has a piece in The New York Times breaking down how Twitter as a social network is especially prone to bot manipulation.
“[The Democrats] made a mistake and they don’t want to recognize this mistake right now,” said Putin. “IP addresses can be invented, a child can do that! Your underage daughter could do that. That is not proof.”
Looks like the White House managed to get talking points to their surrogate before his high profile interview with Megyn Kelly. Because he’s mirroring Donald Trump almost exactly.
Then again, the White House has generally been terrible about getting their surrogates talking points or messaging guidance of any kind. Perhaps Trump has just been echoing the Kremlin’s message all along?
- How the Trump-Russia Data Machine Games Google to Fool Americans
- Trolls are targeting Indian restaurants with a create-your-own fake news site
- Portland Republican says party should use militia groups after racial attack
- The religious origins of fake news and “alternative facts”
- Hillary Clinton was the first casualty in the new Information Wars
- WhatsApp has a viral rumor problem with real consequences
If you’re at Personal Democracy Forum this week, be sure to catch my co-founder Jennifer Fiore on her panel this Thursday at 4 PM EDT. She’ll give an overview of our new venture, The Factual Democracy Project. Details below:
Resourcing Trustworthy, Independent Journalism: This panel will wrestle with how fledgling and emerging news startups earn the trust of their readers, while tapping into resources that will unfailingly support their mission. Is the answer in community-building? High-tech data-powered tools that meet urgent gaps in the journalistic infrastructure? We’ll hear from both veterans and newcomers to the field. Panelists: Jennifer Fiore, Bill Frischling, Wendell Potter, Jay Rosen. Moderated by Sarah Bartlett. (Sponsored by the Knight Foundation)
There’s been a significant increase in subscribers over the past couple of weeks. I’d like to take a moment to welcome new readers, and thank longtime readers for getting the word out to your friends and colleagues! Email forwards are my second highest source for new subscriptions after Medium. If you liked this week’s email, absolutely forward it.
If you’d like to support Ctrl Alt Right Delete financially, here’s the link.
That’s all for now. Thank you as always to the incredible Nicole Belle for editing.