America’s Next #MAGA Superstars
By Melissa Ryan
If you were tasked with casting a movie meant to appeal to Donald Trump’s base you’d be hard pressed to find better protagonists than the Covington Catholic students. They’re everything Trump supporters love: young white men, religiously educated, Kentuckians, not just politically active but politically active in a way that states their misogyny. They’re also the ideal realization of what Trump’s base fears: innocent young white men targeted by the liberal mob and in danger of extinction. Trump’s coalition is at its heart a white supremacist movement, who seek to preserve white supremacy at any cost. And they see young white men as their most vulnerable resource.
It was inevitable that the Covington Catholic students would become America’s next #MAGA stars. The backlash began immediately online from pro-Trump trolls on Twitter and /r/the_donald. Some 4chan posters, not surprisingly, identified strongly with the students as one of their own. For the larger pro-Trump media, who as a colleague pointed out to me have wanted their own version of the Parkland student survivors for months now, the scramble to reframe them as heroes came at an impressive speed. The base already on board, it took almost no effort to get legacy media to reconsider their initial take. At that point, of course, President Trump felt compelled to express his support as well.
— David Hogg (@davidhogg111) January 23, 2019
For those of us who research, and report on information warfare it’s been frustrating to watch legacy media get duped yet again by a counter-narrative. On Tuesday afternoon the frustration on Twitter was palpable. As Joan Donovan said on Twitter “There is a difference between Covington and manipulation campaigns that rely on viral hoaxing of journalists. Here, the content is not manufactured. It was a real event. It happened. Perception is being manipulated, while evidence is edited.” The Atlantic’s Adam Serwer has a thoughtful piece about the media’s tendency to overcorrect themselves. Deadspin’s Laura Wagner was more blunt, calling out reporters and media outlets who fell into this trap pretty harshly:
Respectable news organizations and journalists, to whom being seen as balanced, level-headed, and more attuned to context and contingency than the reactive social-media mob is more important than reporting the most accurate version of the truth as best they can tell it, backed off, following Reason’s lead and doing the work of the gibbering masturbators who had risen up in defense of the MAGA teens. They were all too happy to say that the sky was not blue if it meant burnishing their credentials as serious and objective, and fell over each other to back away from what was right in front of their eyes.
That this happened doesn’t surprise me but the speed and efficiency at which it happened is unsettling. Pro-Trump media have mastered their craft, optimized their tactics, and legacy media are just as vulnerable as they were three years ago. The Guardian’s Jason Wilson outlines the steps pro-Trump media takes pretty much every time. 1. “Reframe the debate as soon as possible” 2. “Pick your narratives” & 3. “Focus on the extremes of the other side.” And Rewire’s Jodi Jacobson points out that legacy media were all too happy to excuse the Covington students and recenter the story around whiteness.
It’s worth noting that the right doesn’t even need to get the America public on these kids’ side. All they need is to create enough confusion so that people feel like they can’t tell truth from fiction and tune out entirely or decide that forming an opinion or speaking out at all would be unfair to the students. Based on how many smart, informed, well-meaning people in my own life have taken that tack, I’d say mission accomplished.
A lot of you have asked me this week if the original release of the video was an act of information warfare designed to inflame everyone. Given the mysterysurrounding the original Twitter account, it’s suspension, and eventual deletion I’m not surprised that there are a lot of questions surrounding how the video got out there. At first glance, it reads like a potential weaponized amplification campaign, but I have an alternative theory that I don’t think has been considered yet. Perhaps the person who released the video on Twitter just wanted to hide their identity, a perfectly reasonable thing to do when you consider how they themselves would inevitably become a target. We have no way to know for certain, but sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.
Like Ctrl Alt-Right Delete? Subscribe to receive the newsletter every Sunday in your inbox.
Transatlantic Hate on the Horizon
by Simon Murdoch
The far right have increasingly worked across borders in recent years, supporting one another’s campaigns and sharing tactics, tropes and stages at conference halls and gatherings in Europe, the US and beyond. Online deplatforming successes in 2018 have put further pressure on the far right to act in concert offline and the narrative that the far right face shared threats – from Muslims, migrants and ‘globalists’ – continues to draw them ever closer together.
This year will see events on both sides of the Atlantic (and elsewhere) likely spurring this on further, not least Britain’s looming March departure from the EU, the mobilization of the far right around the European Parliamentary elections in May, and the run-up to the 2020 elections in the US.
In such a climate, it is more important than ever to monitor and uncover the international movements of the far right to understand and anticipate their intentions both at home and abroad. To this end, HOPE not hate have profiled some of the upcoming gatherings of the international far right, with a focus on the movements of American and European figures across the Atlantic.
- The Anti-Defamation League is out with a new report Murder and Extremism in the United States in 2018. Among their findings: “2018 was a particularly active year for right-wing extremist murders: Every single extremist killing — from Pittsburgh to Parkland — had a link to right-wing extremism.”
- First Draft announced that they’re expanding and opening offices in New York and London. And if fighting “disinformation disorder” is your jam they also have some job openings.
- Trapped in a hoax: survivors of conspiracy theories speak out (The Guardian)
- How “Pick-Up Artists” Morphed Into The Alt-Right (The Nib)
- #BuildTheWall data visualizations & high-volume influencer networks (Medium)
- The Unbelievable Story Of The Plot Against George Soros (Buzzfeed)
- How the ‘cultural Marxism’ hoax began, and why it’s spreading into the mainstream (Daily Kos)
- What I Learned Inside the Lonely, Sad World of QAnon Facebook Groups (Vice)
- Why is This Business Marketing Software to Far-Right and Conspiracy Theorist Audiences? (Right Wing Watch)
Have questions or feedback? Reply directly to this email. I read all the responses and reply to most.
Until next week!